Panthers Draft Wide Receiver Tetairoa McMillan, Sparks Controversy

The Carolina Panthers' selection of wide receiver Tetairoa McMillan in the first round of the NFL draft has sparked debate among team legends and league analysts. Steve Smith Sr., a former Panthers receiver, has repeatedly criticized the pick, arguing that McMillan's skill set is redundant given the current roster and expressing a preference for a faster receiver like Matthew Golden. Smith also questioned whether McMillan is a true game-changer, noting the team's defensive needs. In contrast, Cam Newton, another franchise great, praised the pick for addressing a key offensive need but advised McMillan to focus on film study and professional growth, referencing past concerns about his preparation habits. League executives have compared McMillan favorably to Tee Higgins, suggesting his size and talent could make him a top receiver and a strong addition for quarterback Bryce Young. The selection reflects a shift in the Panthers' draft philosophy and has generated both optimism and skepticism regarding the team's direction.