Sigourney Weaver Defends David Fincher's Alien 3 as Unique Despite Criticism

Sigourney Weaver expressed strong support for Alien 3 and its director David Fincher during a panel at New York Comic Con, highlighting the film's distinctiveness compared to the first two Alien movies. She praised 20th Century Fox for taking creative risks by hiring visionary directors to bring fresh perspectives to the franchise. Weaver criticized the original Vincent Ward script, which featured monks in space and had Ripley in a coma for much of the film, and felt Fincher was not given enough time to properly revise the script before filming began. Despite the production challenges and mixed critical reception, Weaver maintained deep affection for the cast, crew, and the film's meaningful place in her career, emphasizing that she judges each Alien film on its own merits. She also acknowledged the shock caused by Fincher's decision to kill off several beloved characters, viewing it as a necessary evolution of the story. Overall, Weaver's comments reveal her loyalty to the directors and her belief that Alien 3's starkly different tone and approach helped keep the franchise interesting.